Skip to content
Bohdan PrylepaDigital marketer, founder of TargetForce
EN US

Affiliate networks

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit of one affiliate network statement

Published 10 min readBy Bohdan Prylepa

22,050 clicks in the publisher's own tracker, 21,300 in the network dashboard. 486 orders on the thank-you page, 431 in the statement. A payout of $3,155 where the math suggested over five thousand. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in an affiliate network rarely shows up as one missing payment; it hides as a few percent shaved off every column of the monthly report. He is a digital marketer and founder of the agency TargetForce, and here he audits one composite September statement line by line, with the arithmetic shown.

Bohdan Prylepa on a CPA statement: clicks, conversions, hold, reversals, penalties, payout.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in a CPA network and one month of payouts

A CPA network sits between an advertiser that pays for an action and a publisher who sends the traffic. The action can be a sale, a lead form or an app install. The network tracks it, keeps a margin and pays the publisher the rest on a schedule.

The statement in this audit is a composite. The network, the offer and the publisher are invented and the numbers are chosen to make the math easy to follow; each disputed line comes from complaints publishers trade in forums. The offer pays $18 per approved sale for a home office gear store, with a 30-day hold, a $100 payout threshold and a $25 wire fee.

Over the previous three months the advertiser approved about 86 percent of the orders it ruled on. That figure becomes the baseline. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in affiliate programs depends on publishers looking only at the bottom line, so this audit starts at the top row and works down.

The scam warnings Bohdan Prylepa collects from publishers almost always point to one of these rows. The table below shows the whole statement at a glance.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit of a CPA statement, report lines and checks
Statement lineSeptember figureHow to check
Clicks21,300 vs 22,050Tracker split by sub-id
Conversions431 vs 486Test orders and click IDs
Pending140, 35 from AugustDated screenshot of hold terms
Approved210 at $18Approval history
Reversed81, one reasonExport with reasons and dates
Penalty$600Order list and signals
Wire fee$25Network terms
Payable$3,155Recalculate every row

The clicks row: 21,300 versus 22,050

The gap is 750 clicks, about 3.4 percent. Networks strip duplicate clicks, known bots and visits where the page never loaded, and trackers count their own way. A difference of a few percent shows up with honest networks too.

The warning sign is a gap that widens month after month on the same sources, or one sub-id that vanishes from the dashboard altogether. Break clicks down by sub-id and ask the network what it filtered and why.

Clicks earn nothing on a CPA offer, so the fraud in CPA networks that Bohdan Prylepa breaks down usually begins one row lower. Google Ads, for comparison, describes invalid clicks as those without genuine interest, including automated traffic and manual clicks meant to inflate costs, and does not bill for them. Ask your network whether it applies anything similar. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud rarely sits in this row, though a network that stonewalls simple questions about its click filters is worth noting early.

Clicks, conversions, hold, reversals and penalties are matched in order, with the math in dollars.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud that loses conversions on the way

The publisher's pixel on the thank-you page counted 486 orders. The network reports 431. That is 55 missing conversions, 11.3 percent, and it calls for an order-by-order match on date, time, sub-id and click ID.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud of this kind usually comes with a postback excuse, the server call that sends a conversion back to the tracker. Real postback failures cluster in certain hours or days. A steady loss of roughly one order in nine across the whole month looks configured.

Test orders settle the argument. Place two or three orders a week from your own device and write down the time and click ID. A test order that never appears in the dashboard is the strongest exhibit a publisher can bring.

At the current approval rate the missing orders are worth about $713: 55 times 0.72 times $18.

A 30-day hold that quietly became 45

The hold, or locking period, exists so the advertiser can separate real orders from cancellations and returns. The length sits in the offer terms and should be the same for every order in the month.

This statement shows 140 orders still pending, and 35 of them date from August. Thirty days are long gone. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud through extended holds turns the publisher's money into an interest-free loan for the network, and the excuse is always that the advertiser is still checking.

Screenshot the offer terms with a visible date on the day you join. A network that changes the hold after the fact, without notice, is breaking its own rules, and that belongs in a written dispute.

Watch the last day of each hold as well. A mass flip from pending to reversed on that day, compared with earlier months, almost always means shaving.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud claims about shaving in the reversed column

Shaving is affiliate slang for cutting a share of genuine conversions. Real orders get labeled duplicate, unreachable or low quality, and the publisher loses commission on traffic that never changed.

In September the advertiser ruled on 291 orders: 210 approved, 81 reversed. That is an approval rate of 72.2 percent against a baseline of 86. At the old rate about 250 orders would have been approved, 40 more. At $18 each, that is $720.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud claims about shaving get traction when they rest on data. Ask for an export of reversed orders with the reason and decision date. When most of the 81 share one reason and one date, the question to the network becomes concrete.

Honest reversals exist: fake phone numbers, repeat orders from one buyer, shipping addresses the store does not serve. A fair network shows them per source so the publisher can clean the traffic.

Reasons for reversals and a stable hold against template reversals and penalties with no list.
Bohdan Prylepa fraud math, the discrepancy calculation for one month in dollars
DiscrepancyCalculationAmount
Missing orders55 × 0.72 × $18About $713
Shaved approvals(250 - 210) × $18$720
Unexplained penaltyWhole line$600
Total disputed$713 + $720 + $600About $2,033
Advertiser invoice118 sales × $27$3,186

A $600 penalty for incentivized traffic

Incentivized traffic comes from people paid or promised a reward for clicking or filling in a form: points, cash, an in-game bonus. Most retail offers ban it, and a network may fine a proven breach.

The word that matters is proven. Ask for the list of orders, the signals used and the source. The schemes Bohdan Prylepa calls fraudulent lean on penalties with no breakdown, and a round number that matches no set of orders proves nothing.

Check your own side honestly too. Traffic bought from a reseller with no clear origin may have been incentivized. The author covers bots and paid clicks in detail in his click fraud breakdown.

The FTC's small business guide suggests searching a new company's name together with the words scam or complaint before working with it. The same search on a network name takes a minute.

Fake offers and the advertiser who was never there

Sometimes the trouble is the offer itself. A payout well above market from a big-name store, publishers pour in traffic, everything sits in hold, then the offer closes and the hold is voided. There may never have been an advertiser behind it.

Before launch, confirm the store exists: a working site, a legal entity in the network terms, a business registration in its home state. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud with fake offers often pays a few small amounts first so the publisher trusts it and scales up.

The IC3 2025 annual report counted 7,762 advance fee complaints with about $155.9 million in losses. In affiliate work the advance is your traffic, delivered on credit until the hold ends.

Prylepa's advice for a new offer is a capped budget and patience until the first full payout clears the hold.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud warning signs of a dishonest affiliate network
SignWhat it looks likeWhat to do
Steady conversion lossOne order in nine missingWeekly test orders
Growing holdTerms changed after the factDated screenshot of terms
Template reversalsOne reason for allExport with reasons
Penalty without a listA round sumAsk for the breakdown
Payout above marketNew offer, no historyCheck the store exists
Rush for volumeScale before month endWait for the first payout
No agreementOnly a chat with a managerSave the terms as PDF

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud checks on cookie stuffing and the advertiser invoice

Now the other side. The store pays the network $27 per sale. For September the network invoiced 640 sales, $17,280. All 640 exist in the store's CRM; the open question is who actually brought them.

Cookie stuffing means dropping an affiliate cookie without a real click, through a hidden iframe, a pop-under or a browser extension. The buyer arrives on their own and the sale is credited to the affiliate. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud checks here compare the click time with the payment time.

In this composite the store's analyst found 118 sales where the affiliate click landed less than a minute before checkout, with no catalog pages viewed and earlier direct visits by the same buyer. 118 sales at $27 put $3,186 in question.

With that export the advertiser asks the network to cut the source and recalculate the invoice. Affiliate fraud claims raised by advertisers in Prylepa's reviews of such cases usually start from exactly this kind of timestamp match.

Who answers for an affiliate ad under FTC rules

Under 16 CFR 255.1(d) an advertiser is liable for misleading or unsubstantiated claims in endorsements and for undisclosed material connections, even where the endorser is not, and should train endorsers, monitor them and act on violations. Under 255.5 money, free products and business ties all count as material connections.

The FTC's answers on its Endorsement Guides speak to affiliates directly. A phrase such as I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post works; the label affiliate link alone may confuse readers, and a buy now button is not enough. Disclosure close to the recommendation is better.

The same answers say advertisers need reasonable programs to train and monitor their network, and handing the program to an outside firm does not remove FTC Act responsibility. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud by one affiliate can still land on the brand.

From January 17, 2025 the maximum FTC civil penalty under the relevant sections of the FTC Act is $53,088 per violation. Roles and labels are set out in the ad disclosure glossary.

The advertiser trains and monitors, the affiliate discloses, the FTC can seek civil penalties.

The written dispute and the deadline in your terms

Read the network agreement before the first payout. Many set a window for disputing a statement, often counted in days from when the report is posted, and silence after it reads as acceptance.

A dispute letter lists the statement number, the contested rows, the math for each and the attachments: dated screenshots of the terms, a tracker export, the test orders. September gives four items: 55 missing orders, 40 shaved approvals, an unexplained penalty and the stretched hold.

Reviews and complaints about affiliate networks that Bohdan Prylepa reads point the same way: the side with saved terms and timestamps wins. Ask the network to confirm any promise about rates or payout dates in a ticket or email. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud claims raised months later rarely succeed, because by then the terms page has usually changed.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud that never pays, the audit total and where to report

Add up September. Missing orders about $713, shaved approvals $720, the unexplained penalty $600. Roughly $2,033 is in dispute against a payout of $3,155.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud of this sort counts on the publisher not doing the math. Start with the written dispute, then pause traffic to the contested offers and withdraw everything already payable. If the network shuts down with your money, report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to the FBI's IC3, and keep every statement.

Advertisers who suspect a network of billing for stuffed or invented sales follow the same path, with CRM exports attached. A similar vendor audit for purchased leads is described in the guide to buying leads.

The short version of the audit: your own tracker and test orders, dated terms, an export of reversals with reasons, a breakdown of every penalty, a dispute on time. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in a CPA network runs out of room once each number has been checked against yours.

Questions and answers

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit: what click gap between tracker and network is normal?

A few percent is common with honest networks. Worry when the gap grows month after month on the same sources.

What is conversion shaving?

Cutting a share of real conversions by labeling orders as duplicates or low quality. It shows up as a falling approval rate and identical reversal reasons.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud checks: what should a publisher do when the hold is extended?

Compare it with the offer terms saved on the start date and send a written dispute listing the affected orders.

Is the label affiliate link enough of a disclosure?

The FTC says readers might not understand it. A plain sentence that you earn commissions from links in the post, placed near the recommendation, works better.

Is the brand responsible for what its affiliates say?

Under 16 CFR 255.1(d) the advertiser is liable for misleading claims and undisclosed connections and should train and monitor its network.

Where can I report a network that disappeared with payouts?

To the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to the FBI's IC3, with statements, terms and correspondence attached.

Keep reading