Skip to content
Bohdan PrylepaDigital marketer, founder of TargetForce
EN UK

Affiliate networks

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit of one UK affiliate network statement

Published 10-minute readBy Bohdan Prylepa

The statement lands on a Friday: 15,800 clicks, 352 sales, £1,599 to pay. The publisher, who runs an outdoor kit blog from Leeds, has 16,420 clicks and 398 sales in his own tracker, and last summer a smaller month paid more. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in a UK affiliate network seldom takes the form of one unpaid invoice; it works through small cuts spread across a dozen columns. Bohdan Prylepa, founder of the digital agency TargetForce, takes this composite October statement apart row by row and puts a figure in pounds on every gap.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit, cover of the UK article on affiliate payouts
Bohdan Prylepa on a CPA statement: clicks, conversions, hold, reversals, penalties, payout.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in an affiliate network and one October statement

An affiliate network collects money from a retailer for each sale and passes a share to the publisher who referred it. The model only works when both sides see the same numbers. In practice the publisher has a tracker, the retailer has a CRM and the network has its dashboard, and the three rarely agree.

This statement is a composite. The network, the offer and the publisher are made up and the sums are picked for clear arithmetic; each disputed row reflects common publisher complaints. The offer pays £12 per approved sale for an outdoor clothing shop, with a 28-day locking period and a £15 payment fee.

Across the summer the retailer approved about 83 percent of the sales it decided on. That is the benchmark. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in affiliate schemes relies on publishers glancing at the total, so the audit begins at the first column and works down to the amount payable.

Complaints from UK publishers that Bohdan Prylepa has gathered tend to involve lost sales, unexplained declines and penalties. October has all three.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit of an affiliate statement, rows and checks for UK publishers
Statement rowOctoberCheck
Clicks15,800 vs 16,420Tracker by source
Sales352 vs 398Control purchases
Pending104, 28 from SeptemberDated copy of the terms
Approved172 at £12Summer approval rate
Declined76, one reasonDeclines export
Penalty£450List of sales
Payable£1,599Recalculate each row

Clicks: 15,800 on the dashboard, 16,420 in the tracker

That is 620 clicks apart, roughly 3.8 percent. Networks discard repeat clicks and obvious bots, and trackers have their own rules, so a modest gap that stays steady is normal.

Look at the trend and at each source. If last quarter the gap sat near 2 percent and now one channel alone has doubled, ask the network in writing what it filtered from that channel.

Clicks are not paid on a cost-per-sale offer, which is why the fraud in affiliate networks that Bohdan Prylepa analyses tends to start one row further down, where every lost line costs money.

Keep a simple reconciliation sheet: date, tracker clicks, dashboard clicks, gap in percent. After two or three months you will know the normal level for your traffic and spot any jump at once.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit, how a UK publisher reconciles a monthly affiliate statement
Clicks, sales, locking period, declines and penalties are checked from top to bottom in pounds.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud that drops sales between tracker and dashboard

The tracker logged 398 sales, the network shows 352. Forty-six are missing, about 11.6 percent. That calls for a line-by-line match: date, time, source and the click reference the network assigned.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud of this type often blames a postback delay. Genuine outages appear in patches, on particular days or hours. When roughly one sale in nine vanishes evenly all month, it deserves a formal query.

Control purchases help. Every few days make a small purchase through your own link and note the time and click reference. A control sale missing from the dashboard is very hard to argue away.

At October's approval rate the missing sales are worth about £381: 46 multiplied by 0.69 and by £12.

A 28-day locking period stretched past six weeks

The locking period lets the retailer weed out returns and cancellations before commission is confirmed. Its length is in the programme terms and should apply equally to every sale.

The statement still lists 104 sales as pending, 28 of them from September. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud through stretched locking periods leaves the publisher funding the network for free while the retailer is said to be validating.

Under section 13 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, a business providing a service is expected to use reasonable care and skill, subject to the Act's exceptions. Keep a dated copy of the terms from the day you joined: it is the fastest way to settle a timing dispute.

Look closely at the final day of each locking period too. A wave of pending sales turning into declines on that date, set against previous months, is the clearest sign of shaving.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud claims about shaving in the declined column

Shaving means cutting a share of genuine sales. Real orders are marked duplicate, returned or invalid, and the publisher loses commission on traffic that has not changed.

October: decisions on 248 sales, 172 approved and 76 declined. Approval 69.4 percent against a benchmark of 83. At the summer rate about 205 would have been approved, 33 more, worth £396.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud claims about shaving stand up when backed by data. Ask for a declined-sales export with the reason and the decision date. If most declines share one reason and land on the last day of the locking period, the query becomes specific.

Fair declines happen: invented addresses, repeat orders, buyers outside the delivery area. An honest network shows them per source so the publisher can tidy up the traffic.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud sums, the October discrepancy worked out in pounds
What is disputedWorkingPounds
Lost sales46 × 0.69 × £12About £381
Shaved approvals(205 - 172) × £12£396
Penalty with no evidenceWhole row£450
Publisher total£381 + £396 + £450About £1,227
Retailer invoice74 sales × £19£1,406

A £450 penalty for incentivised traffic

Incentivised traffic comes from people rewarded for a click or a sign-up: cashback points, cash, a bonus in a game. Most retail programmes forbid it, and a network may penalise a proven breach.

Proven is the key word. Request the list of sales, the signals relied on and the source. The schemes Bohdan Prylepa describes as fraudulent depend on penalties with no breakdown. A round £450 that matches no set of sales proves nothing on its own.

Be honest about your own sources as well. Traffic bought from a reseller with no clear origin may have been incentivised. The author explains bots and paid clicks in his click fraud guide.

If the network does supply a list, match it against your tracker: timestamps, sources, the share of sales from one device or address range. A fair penalty covers specific sales and equals their value at the programme rate. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud reveals itself in a round figure tied to no sale at all.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud checks, cookie stuffing compared with a genuine affiliate click
A read review and a deliberate click against a hidden frame and payment a minute later.

Phantom offers and the retailer who never existed

A commission a third above market, a programme launched yesterday, a manager urging more traffic before month end. A few weeks on the programme closes, pending sales are voided and the network blames a rogue retailer.

Check who is behind both the offer and the network. Companies House shows a company's registered address, incorporation date and current and past officers free of charge, and lets you subscribe to free alerts about changes.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud with phantom offers often pays a couple of small amounts first to win trust and bigger volumes. Prylepa suggests launching any new programme on a capped budget and scaling only after the first full payment clears the locking period.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud red flags of a dishonest UK affiliate network
Red flagExamplePublisher response
Even loss of salesOne in nine never arrivesControl purchases
Endless locking periodSeptember sales still pendingTerms dated at sign-up
One decline reasonMost declines on the last dayExport with decision dates
Penalty with no listOnly a totalDispute the row
Brand-new programmeCommission a third above marketCompanies House check
Pressure for volumeMore traffic before month endWait for the first payment

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud checks on cookie stuffing, the retailer's view

The retailer pays the network £19 per sale. For October it was invoiced for 470 sales, £8,930. Every one of them is in the CRM; the question is who really sent the buyer.

Cookie stuffing plants an affiliate cookie without a deliberate click, using a hidden frame, a pop-up or a browser add-on. The customer arrives on their own and the sale is credited to the affiliate. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud checks on this compare click time with checkout time.

The shop's analyst found 74 sales where the affiliate click came less than a minute before payment, with no product pages browsed and earlier direct visits. At £19 each that puts £1,406 in doubt. Affiliate fraud complaints from retailers in Prylepa's case notes usually start with this kind of timestamp check. With that export in hand, the retailer asks the network to switch the source off and rework the invoice.

Who is responsible for affiliate ads under the CAP Code

ASA advice on affiliate marketing, dated 22 March 2023, says both the business and the affiliate are responsible under the CAP Code, even where the affiliate created the ad alone. Affiliate content must be obviously identifiable as marketing, on social media from the outset.

Under CAP Code rule 2.1 marketing must be obviously identifiable, and under rule 2.3 marketers must make commercial intent clear. Rulings cited in that advice found labels such as may earn an affiliate commission, *affiliate and #collab insufficient.

Rule 3.1 bars materially misleading ads, and rule 3.7 requires documentary evidence for objective claims before publication. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud by one partner promising a discount that does not exist still lands on the retailer. Rule 1.8 places primary responsibility on marketers while agencies and publishers also accept the Code.

The CMA's guidance for brands on social media endorsements (with the caveat that it covers influencer posts generally) says brands should require Ad labels in contracts and check content themselves. Roles are set out in the ad labelling glossary.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud and affiliate ads, responsibilities under the CAP Code in the UK
Both sides are responsible, the ad must be identifiable, claims need evidence, reports go to ASA.

Raising a dispute: the maths, the wording, the evidence

Write the dispute while the terms and exports are fresh: statement number, contested rows, the calculation for each and attachments such as dated screenshots, the tracker export and control purchases. Name a reply deadline in the letter itself.

Many network agreements set a window for challenging a statement, after which it is treated as accepted. Check yours on day one and diary the date.

Reviews and complaints about affiliate networks that Bohdan Prylepa reads share a lesson: the side that saved the terms wins. Bogdan Prilepa, as the name is sometimes spelt, advises asking for any promise on rates or payment dates in an email or ticket.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud disputes go faster when the letter quotes the programme terms word for word, with the date they were saved and the clause number.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud with vanished payouts, the total and where to report

Tally October. Lost sales about £381, shaved approvals £396, the unexplained penalty £450. Around £1,227 is in dispute against £1,599 paid.

Bohdan Prylepa: fraud on this scale bets on publishers not checking. After the written dispute, pause traffic to contested programmes and withdraw everything payable. If the network has disappeared with the money, report it to Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040, which replaced Action Fraud in England, Wales and Northern Ireland on 4 December 2025.

Scam ads in paid placements go to the ASA through its Report an online scam ad form, which forwards reports to the NCSC. A similar check on lead suppliers is covered in the guide to buying leads.

The audit in one line: your own tracker and control purchases, dated terms, a declines export, a breakdown of every penalty and a dispute on time. Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in an affiliate network has nowhere left to hide once each figure has been reconciled with your own.

Questions answered

Bohdan Prylepa fraud audit: how can a publisher spot lost sales?

Match the tracker against the dashboard sale by sale and make regular control purchases. An even loss all month is more worrying than a one-off outage.

What should I do if the locking period is extended without notice?

Show the network the programme terms dated at sign-up and send a written dispute listing the affected sales.

Bohdan Prylepa fraud checks: what can I demand after a penalty for incentivised traffic?

The list of sales, the signals used and the source. Without a breakdown, dispute the whole row.

Who is responsible for an affiliate ad in the UK?

ASA advice says both the business and the affiliate are responsible under the CAP Code, and the ad must be obviously identifiable as marketing.

How can a retailer detect cookie stuffing?

By the time between the affiliate click and checkout, by sales with no product pages viewed and by earlier direct visits from the same buyer.

Where do I report a network that vanished with my commission?

To Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040, with statements, terms and emails attached.

Further reading