SEO agencies
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in SEO, how vendors sell rankings and how to check them
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in SEO rarely looks like fraud on day one. It looks like a slick proposal, a dashboard full of green arrows and a promise that your business will be number one on Google within a month. Bohdan Prylepa, a digital marketer and founder of the agency TargetForce, breaks down the five schemes dishonest SEO vendors run on American businesses: guaranteed rankings, fake engagement, paid links and private networks, reports built on keywords nobody types, and domains or accounts held in the agency's name. Then the practical part: how to vet a vendor before the first invoice, what to write into the contract and where to report it in the US.
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in SEO and the five schemes vendors sell
Search engine optimization is slow and hard to audit. Results take months, the first report arrives in week one, and few business owners know how to read it. That gap is where a dishonest vendor lives: the client pays every month and sees charts nobody can verify.
There are five schemes worth knowing. A guaranteed top ranking on a fixed deadline. Fake engagement from bots or paid clickers. Bought links and private site networks dressed up as link building. Reports on keywords with no real search volume. The domain, hosting and search accounts registered to the vendor so the client cannot walk away.
Each one can pass for normal work when you see it alone. According to Bohdan Prylepa, fraud in SEO survives only as long as the client never opens the raw data. So his first question to any vendor is simple: which numbers can I check myself, without you?
Guaranteed number one rankings: what Google itself says
Google's own help page for site owners, Do you need an SEO?, is blunt: no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. If a vendor guarantees that its changes will put you in first place, Google's advice is to find someone else.
The same page lists more warning signs. Vendors who claim a special relationship with Google. Anyone selling priority submission to Google. Firms that email you out of the blue, and firms that are secretive or will not clearly explain what they plan to do to your site.
The FTC has seen this pitch at scale. In May 2018 it announced a court order halting a robocall operation that falsely claimed to represent Google, threatened small businesses with removal from search results and promised first-place or first-page placement. Victims paid $300 to $700 to claim and verify a listing, and $949.99 plus monthly payments of $169.99 or $99.99 for a supposedly guaranteed top spot.
In August 2020 the FTC mailed refunds totaling more than $700,000 to 4,467 small business owners from that case, an average of $158.32 each. That is less than the smallest fee the operation charged, and a useful reminder that the guarantee was the bait.
| Promise | What it really means | How to check |
|---|---|---|
| Number one in 30 days | Not even Google can guarantee it | Ask who picked the keywords |
| Special relationship with Google | No such thing exists | Google says walk away |
| We boost behavioral signals | Bots or paid clickers | Compare visits with leads |
| Link building package | Links bought for rankings | Monthly list of every link |
| Forty keywords in the top three | Keywords with no searches | Impressions in Search Console |
| We will register the domain for you | You cannot leave easily | Registrant in domain records |
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud with fake traffic and bots
Some vendors sell behavioral signals: bots or paid workers search for your keyword, click your listing, scroll a few pages and stay. On a vendor dashboard it looks like real interest.
Google calls the practice of sending automated queries to Google machine-generated traffic and lists it in its spam policies. Violations are caught by automated systems and, when needed, by human review. Sites that break the policies may rank lower or not appear in results at all.
You can usually spot it before any penalty. If organic visits on two or three keywords jump while calls and form fills stay flat, Bohdan Prylepa asks the vendor in writing where the growth came from and files the answer with the monthly report.
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud with fake engagement also ruins the client's own analytics. Bot sessions mix with real ones, so conversion rates, landing page reports and audience data stop meaning much, and every later decision about pages and budgets rests on numbers that were never real.
Paid links and private networks: how fraud hides behind link building
Google defines link spam to include buying or selling links for ranking purposes, excessive link exchanges, partner pages made only for cross-linking, and links created by automated programs or services. That covers most of what a cheap link building package delivers.
Private networks are often built on expired domains with an old backlink profile. Google calls this expired domain abuse: buying an expired domain and repurposing it primarily to manipulate search rankings.
Paying to appear on another site is legal. Google asks that paid links carry rel=sponsored, and a tagged link can send visitors without passing ranking value. A vendor who promises ranking gains specifically from buying links is selling the thing Google penalizes.
Bohdan Prylepa asks for a monthly list of every placed link with the page URL, date, price and tag. Google also notes that you should never have to link to your SEO, and that vendors who talk about link popularity schemes deserve a wide berth.
Reports built on keywords nobody searches
The quietest scheme lives in the report. The vendor shows forty keywords in the top three, and all of them are long and oddly specific: your company name plus a street, a rare product and neighborhood combination. The rankings are real. The searchers are not there.
Checking takes an evening. The Performance report in Google Search Console shows clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position for each query, by default for the past three months. A first-place ranking on a query with zero impressions earns nothing.
Nobody can guarantee a number one ranking; fake engagement and bought links lead to penalties; reports get checked against Search Console; the domain and accounts stay in your name; if you were cheated, report it to the FTC.
For Bohdan Prylepa, fraud of this kind ends the day the client owns the Search Console property and gives the vendor user access. Reports then come from the same data the owner sees.
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud through domain and account control
The most expensive scheme surfaces when you try to leave. The domain is registered to the vendor, hosting sits on its account and only the vendor knows the admin password. On paper the site is theirs, and the handover happens on their terms.
ICANN explains that moving a domain from one registrar to another requires an Auth-Code that the registrar issues to the domain holder, also called the registrant or registered name holder. If the vendor is listed as registrant, the vendor gets the code. Check who that is before the first invoice.
Search Console has verified owners, who proved ownership with a token, and delegated owners, added by a verified owner. Only owners can grant permissions. A removed owner loses access at once, but the verification token stays on the site and can be used to verify again until you delete it.
Bohdan Prylepa takes access back in a fixed order: domain first, then hosting and a full site backup, then the admin panel, Search Console and analytics. Every step gets confirmed by email.
| Asset | Whose name | How to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Domain | Your company as registrant | Registrar records |
| Auth-Code | Issued to the registrant | Request from the registrar |
| Hosting | Your account and card | Invoices to your company |
| Admin panel | Your owner login | Vendor role can be revoked |
| Search Console | You as verified owner | Old tokens deleted |
| Content and code | Copyright assigned to you | Signed written assignment |
Who owns the content: Prylepa on US copyright basics
Under 17 U.S.C. 201(a), copyright initially belongs to the author. The US Copyright Office explains in Circular 30 that a commissioned work counts as a work made for hire only for nine listed types of work, and only if both parties agree to it in a signed written instrument.
Under 17 U.S.C. 204(a), a transfer of copyright is not valid unless it is in writing and signed by the owner of the rights. Without that clause, the articles, product descriptions and code a vendor wrote for your site may not be yours to keep when the contract ends.
The fix is a written assignment of all copyright in deliverables to the client, plus a monthly list of what was delivered. Check where the files physically live too: content in the vendor's cloud folder stays with the vendor whatever the contract says.
Articles a vendor placed on other people's websites alongside your links are a separate case. Those pages are not yours, they can be edited or deleted after you part ways, so keep a copy of each text together with the monthly link list.
How Bohdan Prylepa vets an SEO vendor before paying
Google suggests a set of questions for any SEO: examples of previous work, whether they follow Google Search Essentials, what results to expect and in what timeframe, how they measure success, their experience in your industry and your city, how long they have been in business, and whether they will share every change they make to your site.
The FTC's guide for small businesses adds two habits. Search a new company's name together with the words scam or complaint before you sign. Check every invoice closely, because scammers try to get businesses to pay for advertising or listings that do not exist.
Bohdan Prylepa adds a transparency test: ask the vendor to describe in writing what they will do to the site in month one. A vendor who refuses to explain is exactly what Google tells you to be careful about.
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud often arrives as a cold call or an email from a firm you never contacted. Google advises the same skepticism toward unsolicited email about search engines, and the 2018 FTC case shows how far a cold pitch can go once it borrows a famous brand name.
The contract: five clauses that protect the client
A clear scope of work is the first protection. List the tasks, the pages they cover and the deadlines, so that unfinished work can be shown line by line if there is ever a dispute.
The five clauses Bohdan Prylepa insists on: domain, hosting, admin panel and Search Console in the client's name; a keyword list with search volume attached before work starts; a monthly list of placed links with URLs and prices; a written ban on fake engagement and buying links for rankings; and copyright in all deliverables assigned to the client.
Payment should follow numbers the client can see without the vendor: impressions and clicks in Search Console, leads in the CRM, tasks signed off on a monthly statement. Paying for positions on a keyword list the vendor wrote does not belong in the contract.
Ask, too, whether any part of the work will go to subcontractors. Link placement and content are often farmed out, and the contract should name who does what and state that the vendor remains responsible for anything a subcontractor does on your site.
Manual actions: getting a site back into Google
A manual action means a human reviewer at Google decided that pages on the site break the spam policies. Some or all of the site stops showing in results, and searchers see no warning. The owner is notified in the Manual actions report and in the Search Console message center.
Once every listed issue is fixed on every affected page, you select Request Review. Google says most reconsideration reviews take several days or weeks.
Google also reminds owners that they are ultimately responsible for the actions of any companies they hire, and that an irresponsible SEO can get a site removed from the index entirely. Keep the old vendor's reports, link lists and emails before you start cleaning up.
The cleanup itself starts with the old vendor's full link list. Bought links come down or get tagged rel=sponsored, pages written only to carry links are deleted, and the review request spells out what was changed and when.
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud or bad work, where to report in the US
If a vendor took money for work that never happened, report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or by phone at 1-877-FTC-HELP (1-877-382-4357). Your report helps the agency spot patterns and build cases like the 2018 robocall action.
When the scheme ran online, the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center is the other address. IC3 describes itself as the central hub for reporting cybercrime, and a complaint filed at ic3.gov can be shared with federal, state, local or international law enforcement.
Many disputes stay civil: the work was poor and the vendor will not refund. Then a written demand with a deadline comes first and court comes next. Either way, keep the contract, statements, reports, Search Console exports and every email about keywords and links.
| Situation | Where | What to attach |
|---|---|---|
| Manual action in Google | Search Console, Request Review | List of fixes and removed links |
| Vendor took money for no work | ReportFraud.ftc.gov | Contract, invoices, reports |
| Scheme ran online | IC3 at ic3.gov | Emails, payment records |
| Fake Google robocall | FTC, 1-877-FTC-HELP | Call date, number, payments |
| Vendor keeps the domain | Written demand, then court | Contract, emails, domain records |
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud checklist for SEO clients
Domain, hosting, admin panel and Search Console in your name. Keywords agreed before work starts and checked against impressions. A monthly link list. A written ban on fake engagement and paid links for rankings. Copyright assigned to you. No guaranteed number one.
The schemes in this breakdown work on clients who only read the bottom line of a report. One hour a month in your own Search Console and analytics closes most of the gaps long before a penalty.
Bohdan Prylepa covers how to vet a marketing agency before the first payment and click fraud in paid ads in separate articles. More about Bohdan Prylepa, and new articles on the home page.
Questions and answers
Bohdan Prylepa fraud guide: how do you spot a dishonest SEO vendor?
A guaranteed ranking and deadline, a refusal to explain the work, reports on keywords the vendor picked, and a request to register your domain or hosting in the vendor's name.
Can any SEO agency guarantee a number one ranking on Google?
No. Google's help page for site owners says no one can guarantee a number one ranking and advises finding someone else if a vendor promises one.
What happens to a site when a vendor buys links for rankings?
Google treats buying links for ranking purposes as link spam. The site may rank lower or disappear from results, sometimes after a manual action.
Bohdan Prylepa fraud advice: the vendor registered my domain, what now?
Moving a domain requires an Auth-Code issued to the registrant. If the vendor is the registrant, send a written demand under the contract and go to court if needed.
Who owns the content an SEO vendor writes for my site?
Copyright starts with the author. A transfer to you is valid only in writing and signed by the owner, so the contract needs a written assignment.
Where can I report an SEO vendor that took money and did nothing?
Report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or 1-877-FTC-HELP, and to IC3 at ic3.gov if the scheme ran online.
Keep reading
- Bohdan Prylepa: scam signs in podcast ad sales, one host read from brief to report
Bohdan Prylepa: scam warning signs in podcast ads. IAB Tech Lab downloads, FTC disclosure, offer codes, insertion orders and where to report a fake seller.
- Bohdan Prylepa: reviews of email marketing agencies, one campaign from list to report
Bohdan Prylepa: reviews of email marketing agencies. Lists and consent, SPF, DKIM, DMARC, padded reports, CAN-SPAM and the FTC rule on fake reviews.
- Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in AI ad creatives, one ad from generation to takedown
Bohdan Prylepa: fraud in AI ad creatives and deepfakes. One ad from generation to takedown: borrowed faces, AI testimonials, FTC rules and reporting.